Re: RARA-AVIS: Surprise Endings

From: Tony Burton (
Date: 13 Nov 2005

And I understand and agree with what you say, DJ. There were some others here who were saying, in effect, "these things offend me, so I'm not going to read this kind of literature." Problematically, the kind of story that this list/group deals with, is specifically about morally reprehensible behavior. I didn't read The Confession, and probably won't, because I am just too busy these days and am therefore very selective.

I think this avian's feather's were ruffled because of the "paint with a broad brush" view. It's like someone else said, denying oneself literature from a period of time where (for instance) racism and classism were considered the norm really cuts out a large chunk of very good stories.

So, in essence, you and I don't disagree. I just pontificated a little too much!


--- In, DJ-Anonyme@w... wrote:
> Tony wrote:
> "In other words, why is it OK to write about some morally offensive
> behaviors, but not OK to write about others?"
> Short version, I'd say it's okay to write about all of those behaviors.
> Racism, sexism, classism, homophobia, etc, can be as fascinating a
> subject as murder, corruption, etc; put them all together and you've got
> a book I would read. My problem comes when any one of these is
> unexamined (by the author, it's fine if the character is unware f things
> about him/herself), when a racial slur is overused for no reason other
> than to shock or, worse, without even thinking (again, by author, not
> character). Saying people actually say it isn't enough. People say
> "fuck" all the time, but it can have far more effect in a book when used
> sparingly, with a purpose.
> As for non-PC language getting more criticism than morally reprehensible
> actions, well, it may be rare to criticize a book for including bribery,
> murder, rape, etc, seldom are those acts included without a well thought
> out reason, and seldom are the most vicious acts depicted in a positive
> way (except when meting out vengeance). In fact, wasn't that what the
> controversy was over The Confession (well, at least among those who
> actually read it before calling for its burning), that there wasn't
> strong authorial disapproval against the main character and his actions?
> Murder is pretty much seen as universally bad in crime lit (with a few
> rare, well rationalized exceptions), but gratuitous racial slurs can
> actually be mistaken as a sign of how edgy a writer is.
> Mark

------------------------ Yahoo! Groups Sponsor --------------------~--> Get fast access to your favorite Yahoo! Groups. Make Yahoo! your home page

RARA-AVIS home page:
  Yahoo! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:

This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : 13 Nov 2005 EST