On Jan 7, 2009, at 10:35 PM, rara-avis-l@yahoogroups.com wrote:
> Now Kevin, at least, you seem to be basing your judgements upon
> actually
> having read a few of these books, but are you reading them as would
> their target audience? Wouldn't these exaggerated, cliche,
> stereotypical bad black men resonate differently in that different
> cultural context? Basing my assumption more on friends I know who are
> big fans than any actual sales figures, isn't the primary audience for
> this genre black FEMALE? And isn't the emphasis (again, based on chats
> with fans, not having actually read them) of these books more on the
> black women who love men who have embraced these stereotypes than on
> the
> men themselves? If so, it'd make perfect sense that the men would be
> exaggerated stereotypes, just as bad boys are exaggerated in all chick
> lit.
I'm beginning to think you're right. Just as there's a surprisingly
large market for gay male erotica among women, so too does a lot of
this stuff seem to be aimed at the romance market -- or at least a
very uncritical target audience. I think I was mislead by the
settings, which had me hoping for some gut-level homegrown, possibly
hip-hop version of THE WIRE. I got Fabio in blackface instead.
And yes, I'm fully aware of the echoes of previous cultural debates in
my gripes about urban fiction. But I want to make it clear -- I'm not
against the idea of this stuff (just like I wasn't against much of the
dumbed-down "neo-noir" stuff I railed against a while back) and I
don't want it banned or, er, white washed. But I would like it to be
better written. And less impressed with its own existence.
Even a cliché, in the right hands, can be an intriguing, captivating
character. But cardboard is cardboard, regardless of cultural context.
Plus, I still think "urban fiction" is one of the dumbest and most
meaningless euphemisms I've heard since "African-American." Just the
other day, I heard a Fox announcer discussing African-Americans who
were born and grew up in Europe, apparently unaware of how ridiculous
he sounded.
I dunno. Maybe this stuff will evolve, or more likely it will serve as
a training ground and its better writers will move on to bigger and
better things, just as lesbian pornmeisters like Westlake and Block
moved up to the big leagues.
Kevin Burton Smith
The Thrilling Detective Web Site
New Issue Sort of Up
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : 09 Jan 2009 EST