I don't post much here since I'm still a relative newbie to crime fiction, and I'm mostly here to learn (and I do learn a lot, and appreicate it, although one does have to wade through some fairly tiresome bickering at times).
Anyway, I did want to chime in on the recent question: I for one am still reading John D. MacDonald and really liking what I'm reading.
I have been (slowly) reading the Travis McGee novels in order--next one up is BRIGHT ORANGE FOR THE SHROUD. I have not yet discovered a "private eye" (I know, he's not really one) series I like better, certainly not from that era. As a comparison, I have found the first several McGee novels much better than the first several Parker "Spenser" books, which I also started reading but abandoned after JUDAS GOAT.
I've also been dipping into MacDonald's stand-alones; in the last year or so I've read APRIL EVIL and THE BRASS CUPCAKE. Neither is especially remarkable as a story, but I found each a great read.
Much of the pleasure in JDM comes from the author's "voice"--as a narrator, and of course through his characters, such as McGee, whom it's hard not to read as stand-in for the author. I find MacDonald's musings on society, justice, morality, and human nature interesting and fairly distinct in terms of authorial style. I am well aware, of course, that others can't stand his voice or style, but for me MacDonald has become one of my favorite "crime" writers, and I'm glad I still have a large shelf of his work to get through.
I also find MacDonald's biography fairly remarkably, but then again the more I learn about mid-century crime writers, the more it seems remarkable biographies are to some extent the norm!
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : 07 Oct 2008 EDT