RARA-AVIS: George and cozies

From: Joy Matkowski ( jmatkowski1@comcast.net)
Date: 02 Sep 2002

I get hand-me-downs of that series, which BTW is a police procedural and thus very suitable for discussion this month. The only interesting character is Barbara Havers (SP?), and the others--male and female--are nincompoops IMHO. Anyway, you shouldn't judge a book by its movie.
    But the more interesting part of your comments is that cozies rule. DorothyL has been awash for months with news of the cancellation of various cozy series, and the rationale offered is that only thrillers are best-sellers and there isn't a market for cozies.

Joy, who notes that cozies don't have semi-disrobed young men holding vials of poison on the cover

Frederick Zackel < fzackel@wcnet.org> commented:

> Part of the problem with writing about the opposite sex is fantasizing
> you think the opposite sex is, when in truth you haven't a clue in the
> world. I watched the most recent PBS Mystery series featuring Elizabeth
> George's cozies, figuring watching one of her stories on TV would spare me
> from reading an ARC of one of her books. Her main character Thomas Lynley
> was such "a sensitive male," I puked. He was more sensitive than any
> in the story, especially the 18 yr old murderer who used an axe to behead
> her father. (The only good part of the story. I perked up for that.) A
> sensitive male is what you buy for a postmodern woman who has everything.
> George has no idea what goes on inside a man's head, but her audience can
> identify with her cloying nonsense because their fantasy of what a
> male is corresponds to her fantasy. So she's a big name cozy writer. On
> the other hand I have four fingers and thumb. Ahhh, what I really mean
> how many hard-boiled male writers are only capable of writing "Beautiful
> Girls in Underpants with Machine Guns," which is no less a clueless
> manufactured fantasy. The diff between the cozies & the hard-boiled
> fantasies is women buy books, so cozies rule. The more cozies there are,
> the less reason men have to read. So men read less. Which means more
> cozies get published. Which means --
> I'm such a sensitive male, my wife sent me to the video store to rent Hard
> Eight. She saw it by accident on Bravo, then said it's my kind of story.
> missed it when it came out. Never knew it existed. Had a wonderful time
> with it. I tried checking the rara-avis archives to see what the list has
> said in the past about it, but my Apple 2E isn't awake yet.

# To unsubscribe from the regular list, say "unsubscribe rara-avis" to
# majordomo@icomm.ca.  This will not work for the digest version.
# The web pages for the list are at http://www.miskatonic.org/rara-avis/ .

This archive was generated by hypermail 2b29 : 02 Sep 2002 EDT