RARA-AVIS: Re: RARA-AVIS - Top Ten

james.doherty@gsa.gov
06 Oct 98 15:00:00 -0400 --UNS_gsauns2_2966392553
Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii"
Content-Disposition: inline


Some ten years ago, I wrote an article for the "Special Bouchercon
Issue" of *Mystery Readers Journal* entitled "The Ten Best Private Eye
Novels Ever Written." My choices then were, in chornological order:

1) *Red Harvest* by Dashiell Hammett
2) *The Dain Curse* by Dashiell Hammett
3) *The Maltese Falcon* by Dashiell Hammett
4) *The Big Sleep* by Raymond Chandler
5) *One Lonely Night* by Mickey Spillane
6) *The Long Goodbye* by Raymond Chandler
7) *Double in Trouble* by Richard S. Prather & Stephen Marlowe
8) *Interface* by Joe Gores
9) *Eight Million Ways to Die* by Lawrence Block

For the tenth entry I wimped out and listed my runners-up rather than
a single novel. These were, again in choronological order:

*The Moving Target* by Ross Macdonald
*The Girl Hunters* by Mickey Spillane
*Act of Fear* by Michael Collins
*Gone, No Forwarding* by Joe Gores
*Sugartown* by Loren D. Estelman
*Dead Letter* by Jonathan Valin
*The Million Dollar Wound* by Max Allan Collins

Of course, these are specifically PI novels rather than general
hard-boiled. Were I doing the list now, I might change some things.
Probably include less Hammett; much as I love him, three out of nine
seems excessive on reflection. I'd certainly list an actual tenth
novel rather than wimping out and listing seven more, by calling them
"runners-up." I'd probably include a Jonathan Latimer, with whom I
was unfamiliar ten years ago; most likely *Solomon's Vineyard*. On
reflection, I think Collins's first Heller novel, *True Detective*,
stands the test of time better than *Wound*, which I'd just finished
when I wrote the article. Recent authors who either hadn't yet
debuted or with whom I was unfamiliar, and who I might now consider
include Robert Crais, Sue Grafton, Jeremiah Healy, Dennis Lehane, and
John Lutz. - Jim Doherty

--UNS_gsauns2_2966392553--
#
# To unsubscribe, say "unsubscribe rara-avis" to majordomo@icomm.ca.
# The web pages for the list are at http://www.vex.net/~buff/rara-avis/.