>but can't say I agree with your assessment of
Ferrara's adaptation of Cat
>Chaser, Fred. thought it was a huge botch of what
seemed to be a sure
>slam dunk. most puzzling is the 3rd person voiceover
narrative by
>someone who isn't even a character in the movie. who
is this supposed to
>represent-
>Leonard?
I always assumed the voice was either Leonard, God or Adam
Smith's "unseen
hand."
Personally, I like voiceovers for certain types of film
adaptations,
(particularly noir/HB), but I know many people really hate
them.
I'm also aware that my appreciation of Ferrara's Cat Chaser
is not widely
shared. The thing I like most about it is the way the
conflicts seem to
grow from what seems, at first, a meandering exposition of
the characters
and their situation. There isn't that feeling of cleverness
that exudes
from much writing which uses the caper as an undisclosed
framework to
build a HB/noir story around.
> however, Kelly McGillis is to be lauded for her
incredibly
>brave performance. to get the full measure of it, one
must rent the
>unrated version.
>
This is crucial in other Ferrara films as well. I was talking
to a friend
who had seen the Bad Lieutenant and thought the film was
incoherent. As we
discussed it, it turned out her had seen a rated version
which had done a
rather sloppy job of deleting the scenes that pulled the
story together.
>far better representations of Abel Ferrara's
sensibility would be the
>extremely hardboiled trio of films- Bad Lieutenant,
Dangerous Game and
>King of New York.
>
Agreed. Although, I thought the weakness of Bad Lt was that
it was such a
downward spiral that it didn't have much internal moral
dialog. King of
New York was much more morally complex.
It seemed the film KoNY was a take on Joey Gallo. Does anyone
know if it
was an adapted from a book?
I was also interested in comments about the novel
_Trainspotting_ by
Irvine Welsh. I haven't read it, but the film certainly
seemed to share
many of the defined characteristics of HB fiction as outlined
in previous
discussions.
Fred
-- ----------------------------------------------------------- Down on Ponce by Fred Willard fwillard@mindspring.com http://fwillard.home.mindspring.com/ -----------------------------------------------------------
# # To unsubscribe, say "unsubscribe rara-avis" to majordomo@icomm.ca. # The web pages for the list are at http://www.vex.net/~buff/rara-avis/.