Re: RARA-AVIS: Richard Prather

Gary Warren Niebuhr (piesbook@execpc.com)
Sun, 03 May 1998 09:32:34 -0700 >Can someone explain the appeal of Prather. I don't mean to assault
>anyone's taste, but I have never been able to get more than few pages in
>to a Prather novel. Hackneyed, wooden, generally terrible writing . . .
>does he take a while to warm up or what? Are Shell Scotts better than
>non-series novels?
>
In a recent issue of PW Bruce Taylor, owner of the San Francisco Mystery
Bookstore, was quoted as saying nobody wants to read anything written ten
years prior to today. A few years ago at my library, I tried to have a
series on the Golden Age mysteries, and it failed because the participants
were not interested in playing the game.

I think part of the deal when reading an author like Prather is that you
have to be willing to read the material without a contemporary sensibility.
If you want to read it with contemporary sensibilities for the purpose of
an analysis of the work, fine.

But if you want to read it as a piece of popular genre writing, you need to
approach it without the modern sensibilities. You need to approach it as a
person might have in the 50s or 60s when they were written.

I think Prather fits comfortably into what I call the "screwball" private
eye writers. It might have started with authors like Bellem, Latimer and
Norbert Davis, but the writers like Prather, Avallone, and Goulart were
trying to maintain that sense of fun within the hardboiled genre. And, I
have to admit, although most of the stuff today seems outrageous (also
sexist and racist), I still can read a Prather in a couple of hours and
when I am done say--well, that was kind of fun. Best, GWN.

P.I.E.S. (Private Investigator Entertainment Service)
Catalogs of new and used private eye fiction
Gary Warren Niebuhr, Owner
P. O. Box 341218
Milwaukee, WI 53234
piesbook@execpc.com
<http://www.execpc.com/~piesbook/piescatalog.html>
#
# To unsubscribe, say "unsubscribe rara-avis" to majordomo@icomm.ca.
# The web pages for the list are at http://www.vex.net/~buff/rara-avis/.