Re: RARA-AVIS: List of Best Of

MT (matrxtech@sprintmail.com)
Thu, 01 Oct 1998 09:41:14 -0500 Here's a rough Top 10 list, culled from a much larger one that I put
together a couple of weeks ago while weeding my collection. As usual, 10
is not enough to do justice to the genre. In any case, I think that the
following are all unquestionable hardboiled masterpieces. I do make a
distinction between hardboiled and noir - hence the absence of certain
authors and works.

1. =93The Last Good Kiss=94 by James Crumley

Perhaps the most perfect and beautifully written P.I. novel ever.

2. =93Red Harvest=94 by Dashiell Hammett

The prototype of the ultrahardboiled novel. Lean, mean and cynical
prose; a classic tale of corruption. A perfect gem.

3. =93The Big Sleep=94 by Raymond Chandler

The finest work by the best stylist the field has produced. Endlessly
re-readable.

4. =93Green Ice=94 by Raoul Whitfield

Whitfield was as good as Hammett. Green Ice is his masterpiece - an
unforgettable tale of revenge described by Hammett as "Naked action
pounded into tough compactness by stacatto, hammerlike writing". It's an
apt description.

5. =93The Big Gold Dream=94 by Chester Himes

My favorite among the wonderful Harlem hardboiled fantasies of Chester
Himes. This book perfectly integrates toughness, social criticism,
tenderness, crazy humor, realistic dialogue, and a truly original prose
style.

6. =93Freaky Deaky=94 by Elmore Leonard

What else can you say about something great other than that it is great?
(A line stolen from Dorothy Parker discussing Ring Lardner.) Leonard
shines here, with perfect dialogue, ultrahardboiled characters, and a
plot that is as funny as it is explosive.

7. =93Mongo=92s Back in Town=94 by E. Richard Johnson

A book so tough it's scary. Before Ellroy, there was Johnson. All his
books are great, but this one is an unforgettable classic. After reading
this, the word 'Mongo" will never seem funny again.

8. =93The Big Nowhere=94 by James Ellroy

An enormously ambitious socio-historical hardboiled classic. What Ellroy
did here, no crime writer had done before. The complex plot is perfectly
held together and the characters are truly memorable. A recent
re-reading confirmed its stature as one of the great hardboiled novels
of all time.

9. =93The Friends of Eddie Coyle=94 by George V.Higgins

A perfectly polished cold dish in the ultrahardboiled style of Paul
Cain* and Dashiell Hammett. Not a word is wasted. After the last line,
the reader is left breathless.
=20
10. =93A Little Yellow Dog=94 by Walter Mosley

With this book, Mosley reaches his classicism. The quality of the prose
bears comparison with Chandler, and the story is gripping in its sadness
and realism.

*I had to exclude Paul Cain's "Fast One" because in a recent try at
re-reading it I found it close to indigestible - and incomprehensible.

Regards,

Mario Taboada
#
# To unsubscribe, say "unsubscribe rara-avis" to majordomo@icomm.ca.
# The web pages for the list are at http://www.vex.net/~buff/rara-avis/.