Re: RARA-AVIS: postmodern noir

Bill Hagen (billha@ionet.net)
Fri, 5 Dec 1997 22:17:43 -0600 (CST) Recently Mario writes, "I would place "Lot 49" squarely in the realm of
whimsical-absurd
>fantasy, alongside much of the work of people like Italo Calvino, Julio
>Cortạr, Dino Buzzati, Donald Barthelme, and Raymond Queneau - or
>Tati's film "Playtime". The element of danger is not present in
>Pynchon's novel (at least, I don't see it), and Oedipa is neither a
>heroine or an anti-heroine but a bemused observer. There is no crime or
>hint of one in sight. There is no real conflict and almost no action.
>There is no anger.I would place "Lot 49" squarely in the realm of
>whimsical-absurd
fantasy, alongside much of the work of people like Italo Calvino, Julio
Cortạr, Dino Buzzati, Donald Barthelme, and Raymond Queneau - or
Tati's film "Playtime". The element of danger is not present in
Pynchon's novel (at least, I don't see it), and Oedipa is neither a
heroine or an anti-heroine but a bemused observer. There is no crime or
hint of one in sight. There is no real conflict and almost no action.
There is no anger."

I would agree. One might argue there is danger in Lot 49, but only if you
see as dangerous either being paranoid or discovering that America (70s) is
objectified paranoia. Not quite noir, either in character attitude or
menace, it seems to me. In a sense, noir is a certitude, a definite
shading in the world, and this certitude is exactly what you don't have in
most postmodern fantasy.

Of the late century writers (they seem more modern than postmodern), it
seems to me that playwrights like Pinter and Mamet, like some of the French
New Wave directors, get the menace and sometimes the crime into their work.
I'm reminded that Tarantino thought of Travolta for Pulp Fiction, in part
because he had seen his film performance in Pinter's "Dumb Waiter," which
involves two hit men waiting for their victim.

Bill Hagen
<billha@ionet.net>

#
# To unsubscribe, say "unsubscribe rara-avis" to majordomo@icomm.ca.
# The web pages for the list are at http://www.vex.net/~buff/rara-avis/.