Andrew Kines and I talk about LOTR

Andrew Kines and I are in some advertorial content in The Toronto Star today, talking about how much we loved The Lord of the Rings as boys and how it influenced our lives: My Dinner with Frodo. (Actually, it was lunch: we got together for lunch a few weeks ago and talked for three hours. Andrew boiled it down.)

I first read The Hobbit and then LOTR when I was about eleven. I loved it. I was distraught when it was over and I had to leave Middle Earth. I think I reread it immediately. I read it five or six more times, but I was never a huge LOTR geek. I never read The Silmarillion or any of the other stuff. I did read a fair bit of post-Tolkien Extruded Fantasy Product, like the Belgariad and the Malloreon by David Eddings (which are awful), The Sword of Shannara, and a lot of other similar bilge. Eventually I gave up on fantasy.

I'll never forget how Tolkien captured me as a boy, though. The Lord of the Rings was a major influence on me in lots of ways. I'll never read it again — I tried fifteen years ago and I could no longer stand the language and style — but it was one of the books that turned me into a grown-up reader and, in part and often indirectly, set the course of my life.

(The picture is by Michael Watier. That's me on the left and Andrew Kines on the right.)

Comments

In 1967 I visited a girl I had met as a penpal who lived on the outskirts of Oxford, UK. We were taking a walk through her neighborhood when we passed by an older man wearing a dowdy black coat and a hat, and carrying a cane. As we passed my friend said "Hello". I asked her who it was, and she answered: "That's old man Tolkien. A college Don." My astonished reply: "J R R Tolkien?!" "Yes, why?" LotR hadn't yet made the splash there that it had here, and my friend didn't know that he was famous. I don't know that she ever read the books, but she's still in touch with Tolkien's daughter, who was my friend's English teacher in their version of high school. So I didn't meet him, but I did *see* him, although the picture by now is very faded. - kcoyle
I used to read the LOTR once a year from the ages of about 9 to 14 I think. My father originally read me The Hobbit as bedtime reading over the course of many months when I was probably 7 or so. Definitely formative in my eventual love of recreational reading as well. I still read it from time to time. The language and style don't bother me (I still read SF and occasionally fantasy), but the politics do a bit. -jrochkind

Post new comment